new Mennonite Life logo    December 2005     vol. 60 no. 4     Back to Table of Contents

Exploration: How can understanding "God as Creativity" impact the therapeutic process?

by Elsie Enns Steelberg, M. D. (1)

Elsie Steelberg is staff psychiatrist at Prairie View’s East Wichita outpatient clinic.

Preparing for this seminar has been challenging and mentally stimulating and—I must say—pleasurable. I've struggled with trying to understand God as creativity and how this would help my patients.. Yesterday's lectures, conversations and discussions were helpful in thinking of God as creativity and mystery - and for me it has answered some questions, particularly as to God's relation to our world in the context of the evolutionary process. This winter in China, my husband and I contemplated why 2200 years ago God was involved with Israel and not with the millions (billions) of people in China whose beliefs are totally different. I find that thinking of God as creativity helps in some understanding of God and the various world belief systems. I especially appreciate the warmth Gordon Kaufman brings to serendipitous creativity.

Also, the concept that God is mystery and beyond our understanding has long been something I believed. I like the hymn which speaks of "the wideness of God's mercy," and especially the verses

But we make God's love too narrow by false limits of our own,
And we magnify its strictness with a zeal God will not own.
For the love of God is broader than the measures of the mind
And the heart of the Eternal is most wonderfully kind. (2)

Some years ago, I heard Sallie McFague speak, and later I led a seminar on her book, Models of God. (3) I appreciated her descriptions of the various metaphors for God as mother, friend, lover - as a way to help us understand aspects of God, but that God was still a personal God. At the end of that workshop one woman said loudly—"all right ladies, let's now go back to our hotels and read our Bibles"—clearly not in agreement with what I had said. However, three women came up to say it had been helpful, having been abused by their fathers. The previous year I had spoken to the same convention on depression and a comment in the evaluation said, "next year, get someone who believes God can heal everything." I declined to speak the third year. I cite these reactions because they are indicative of the difficulty people have of thinking of God in other ways.

In dealing with patients I do not bring in religious input unless that is where the patient is. We see people with very severe depressions—some feel alienated from God—some are obsessed that they may be "lost," may have committed the unpardonable sin. This is not necessarily a spiritual issue; it may be an obsessive disorder. Others have gone through or are experiencing tragedies, often overwhelming losses: emotional, financial, divorce, deaths of loved ones including suicide.

For those who believe in God, what has seemed most helpful is the belief that God is with them through these trials. Not that God caused the trials or will make things all right again, but that God shares their suffering. I do not know how God as creativity can meet this need for these individuals in the same way. For some, I have used William Sloan Coffin's response to his son's death, which he related in the Christian Century, that he was comforted in thinking that God was weeping with him when his son drove off the pier and drowned. I understand that Coffin may not now put it this way, but it seems to me that in his time of grief this was helpful.

It was Pascal who said, The heart has reasons of which reason knows nothing, and perhaps Coffin's understanding at that time was of this nature.

I do particularly appreciate and agree that humans need to be responsible for the world - the environment—to save and not destroy it. Human beings can be the comfort needed by those in pain, but many do not have that support system. We say God uses people to do God's work and that we should not pray for what we should be doing. But how do we pray to creativity? Do we expect answers? Or do we simply expect change in ourselves?

How do we pray for a world hit by tsunamis, hurricanes, earthquakes, or the disasters of war? What gives people hope to survive?

If I think of my patients and ask how "serendipitous creativity" would be helpful in the therapeutic process, at least two categories of questions arise—universal and personal.